Season 1 Episode 3: The AI overlords fomenting fears of a ‘permanent underclass’
“[AI boosters] are all locked in, because their reputations are staked on this being true.”
Nick leads a discussion on the idea of the “permanent underclass,” and Mike outlines the different groups of AI boosters propping up the narrative.
- The APM Fallacy: Tech workers are optimizing for “actions per minute” or using agents to do more things faster without considering ROI. Productivity as a video game.
- The Token Reality Gap: When the subsidies end, agents that felt magical become prohibitively expensive.
- The rogues’ gallery of overlords: Dissecting the buckets of AI boosters—from true believers and doomsday cultists to managers using AI to avoid the “witch hunt” of layoffs.
Timestamps
0:00 Intro
1:43 Silicon Valley’s cultural bubble (APM & AI Agents)
8:33 The economic AI bubble
20:40 Who created the permanent underclass story?
22:18 AI doom/human extinction
30:12 Putting AI boosters into buckets
47:55 AI ROI?
53:03 Tech workers embrace permanent underclass anxieties
55:37 Media and investors sleep at the wheel
01:02:10 AI overlords caught in cynical grift
01:09:50 Silicon Valley and UBI
Deeper learning
Mike on Grandpa Shelby and LLMs: misaligned.markets/understanding-large-language-models
Mike on the AI bubble: misaligned.markets/what-to-expect-ai-bubble
V.F. Ridgeway on measuring metrics: nesslabs.com/what-gets-measured-gets-managed
Richard Sutton’s bitter lesson: incompleteideas.net/IncIdeas/BitterLesson.html
$500 million on AI in a month: fastcompany.com/91550884/claude-ai-costs-climb-company-spent-half-a-billion-dollars-in-a-single-month-report
Pro-extinction AI researchers: archive.is/DBSC4
Google’s Larry Page vs Musk on human specieism: archive.is/jBKPn
Nvidia CEO causes quantum stocks to fall: cnbc.com/2025/01/08/quantum-stocks-like-rigetti-plunge-after-nvidias-huang-says-the-computers-are-15-to-30-years-away.html
Eliezer Yudkowsky makes ~$600k writing fanfiction: projects.propublica.org/nonprofitsorganizations/582565917
Ed Zitron on AI compute demand: youtu.be/-5aPsg3rl3g?si=fUmPZN3Jzc8ZuNJP
Reach out
Site: rss.com/podcasts/the-last-enclosure
Bluesky: bsky.app/profile/lastenclosure.bsky.social
Transcript
[Nick]
Welcome everyone to this episode of The Last Enclosure.
[Mike]
We’re your hosts, Mike and Nick. We’ve got a special episode for you today, a follow-up to our last conversation about AI. I think though this is kind of a different through line, talking through a very common talking point that is emerging even as the AI bubble is deflating or popping.
[Nick]
We live in strange times where the bubble popping occurs quite so slowly. But yeah, the important sort of emphasis of today is a concept called the permanent underclass. And this is probably a phrase that will be bandied about with increasing frequency.
And it is being used in sort of tech circles, in sort of oligarchic circles, in a sort of policy walkish side of things. And so hopefully we can kind of distill this into a conversational package and examine it in a timely way.
[Mike]
Yeah. I mean, obviously there’s a lot to talk about with this particular phrasing, sort of its origins, its implications, exactly why people are freaking out about it. Although very interestingly, I just saw a podcast episode from Derek Thompson earlier today, not that I watch him, calling for the claims that AI is going to take jobs.
The job apocalypse, as they’ve been saying, was overblown. Of course, Thompson was one of the earliest voices saying AI was taking jobs. So he’s jumping on the bandwagon as usual.
But anyway, there’s this tension where if you’re living where we are living, people are still talking about the permanent underclass as a serious kind of thing.
[Nick]
As a note, we are speaking to you from the Bay Area, California. So sort of the heart of the beast, if you will.
[Mike]
My bad. Yeah, we mentioned that in the first episode.
[Nick]
Yeah, yeah, yeah. We’ll try to reemphasize that. Yeah.
We are speaking to you from a place, at least, of witnessing it, working near it.
[Mike]
We are in the lion’s den. Indeed, yes. So yeah, there’s some sense that there’s still this fear about the permanent underclass in tech, right?
So there’s this bubble, not the economic bubble, there’s this social bubble, there is this cultural bubble of people working in Silicon Valley and SF. And they are still feeling as if AI, if it won’t take jobs, will allow them to create opportunities that wouldn’t otherwise exist, right? There’s this sense that for all the flaws of LLMs, and we talked about this a bit in previous episodes, the one thing that it does to the user, even in cases where it is useful, is it creates this effect of efficacy, of forward motion, right?
You basically, I liken it to this idea of APM or actions per minute in video games, right? So there are people who are using LLMs to automate workflows. Now, whether or not they are judging the efficiency of these workflows, I don’t know.
But the fact that you can automate all this work, be it redundant work or work that’s not even useful, whatever, but you just feel like you’re doing more things per minute, right? Your APM is going up.
[Nick]
And so even if- In the video game metaphor, this is sort of like, oh, I’m crafting and I’m also training my pet and I’m also gaining these skills or learning this magic. Like, look at all the things I’m doing to get better and upgraded. In real life, seemingly only the LLM is offering that kind of high intensity, high pace skill improvement all the time, every day.
[Mike]
Yeah. It’s not even skills. It’s just literally, I can also, in Silicon Valley- Task handling, yeah.
Task handling. So people in Silicon Valley are not using chatbot interfaces, they’re using agents. An agent for the audience is just basically, it’s a large language model that can prompt itself continuously until a task is done.
So the interface is different, but this idea of agentic kind of workflows being different from LLMs is sort of a misnomer because it’s the same technology. It’s the exact same technology. It’s only, you’ve gotten the LLM to prompt itself to finish a task over time, right?
And so if you’ve got, say, dozens of agents doing loops or whatever, your visible APM has gone up. Now, whether you’ve asked yourself if these tasks should be automated or if even the workflows are being automated correctly, that’s another question, right? But the reason I think, sorry for the long tangent, the reason why I think this permanent underclass idea is still relevant even this late into the bubble is because for true believers, their APM is up.
They must be doing something more efficient. And if their APM is higher than your APM, well, they will join the permanent overclass and you will be remaining in the permanent underclass, right? And so even as the bubble is deflating, for those of us who are in the cultural bubble of SF, there is this sort of self-affirmed notion of, well, even if AI has no ROI, my APM is high.
This will not go away. Someone will find a way to make this work because everyone’s APM is going too high for this to just go away.
[Nick]
Right. And of course, the responsible thing at this structure is to point out that there’s a lot of the fallacy of metrics, right? I’m able to measure more outputs.
Therefore, I am improved. I’m offering more, I’m increasing value. When in fact, it can be a misleading metric.
In fact, often is, but we have to measure and we have to kind of sell ourselves and pitch ourselves using something and that thing should be as objective as possible. So this is kind of what we’ve settled on in this time period right now is this, yeah, this APM sort of abstraction.
[Mike]
Yeah. I mean, it’s not even, I mean, going back to metrics, that’s a good point. So there’s a Peter Drucker business, you can call it business school or business idiot if you’re privy to exitron, the biggest bubble deflator.
Shout out to our boy exitron. So Drucker says, whatever isn’t measured, doesn’t get managed, right? It’s actually an inversion of an earlier quote by, I want to say RF Ridgeway, it’s something like that.
I’ll put it in the show notes, but Ridgeway says something defective, whatever gets measured, gets managed, even when it’s useless to do so. So there’s this sense of, we live in a society where people are looking for metrics that are easy to correlate to measures of success, measures of efficacy, measures of progress. And okay, there are abstractions that do map to kind of crudely to those things.
But sometimes when you go too far in measuring things, well, you end up measuring things that don’t matter, but because they look like they matter, and because those things are going up and up and up and up and up, you kind of just follow the trend line, basically maximizing something that actually doesn’t really matter, right? And so the question for LLM agents is, you know, of the tasks that they’re being automated, because keep in mind with agents, because the LLM is prompting itself over and over and over, and because modern agents like AI workflows involve reasoning models, these are models that actually, before they start a task, they have to actually emit tokens to themselves. It’s as if there is going back to our Leonard Shelby- It’s self-assigning the tokens?
Yeah, yeah. So if you remember in our last episode, we talked about Leonard Shelby, the metaphor of Grandpa Shelby.
[Nick]
Grandpa Shelby, yeah. Sharks again.
[Mike]
So this is as if, because the model has amnesia, this is as if, you know, Shelby is writing before he’s given a task, he’s writing down all the things he has to do, and then looking at that screen board that he just wrote on and saying, okay, right. So, you know, you or I might think to ourselves before doing a task, LLM is like literally verbatim, they have to emit tokens in order to imitate that process of thinking like, okay, my first step is to do this and do that, do this, that, that. And thinking wastes a lot of tokens before the task has even begun, right?
So you’ve got an LLM that is thinking, quote, unquote, writing on the draft board, right, before starting a task, which costs money. And then in order to do the task as an agent has to keep prompting itself, not with reasoning tokens, but with actual tokens to keep continuously finishing the task until it’s done, right? So this is a very, at best, inefficient process, right?
Now, for the user who’s able to automate these workflows, especially if they’re subsidized, or they’re not paying the cost directly, you know, of those tokens, right?
[Nick]
Yeah.
[Mike]
You know, it feels like they’re doing a lot. And they’re doing a lot for cheap, because they’re not paying the full price of the token. And one of the obviously, we’re in a bubble, because well, a lot of these workflows may not be sustainable, if you actually were paying for them on a per token basis.
And that’s sort of like the big, you know, lesson that a lot of people are learning as we’re recording this is that, you know, well, even if it feels like our APM is up, it may not be worth it to do these tasks in these ways, the workflows can still be valuable. It’s just that the cost of doing them this way is way too high. So there’s, you know, this is the core mismatch at the heart of the AI bubble.
And there’s a question of what happens, you know, when the token reality hits everybody, and what they’re going to do, most likely, they’re going to cut back on tokens. And, you know, my thesis has always been, you know, going back to my writing and misaligned markets, you know, when I did talk about the bubble, the thesis has always been, well, look, we have this technology for better or for worse. Now, you know, I believe it’s better for a harmful technology to not have been invented, but these things exist, what will likely happen is people will begin scoping them to tasks where the token costs actually matches the ROI of the task, right?
And maybe that means agents survive, but like it would probably won’t be the agents we have today. Very likely, though, you will have bespoke workflows that are kind of very basic, like to give you an example, I have a home lab, so I’ve played around with the technology just to understand it. And I was reading subreddits, like LLM dev, and a few others.
And, you know, the people who were actually the very, very beginning of the AI takeoff around 2024, 2025, were doing kind of like consultant work where they were basically pitching themselves to companies automating low-hanging fruit, like basic classification tasks using on-premise large-language models. So you feed a model, a bunch of images that need to be, you know, approved, like say a contract or something like that. And this is not actually a real workflow, so don’t worry anyone who’s like saying, are my applications- This job resembles this.
Yeah. But you have some type of document that has a certain type of schema, so you can actually codify, you know, this document has a name, it has a, you know, blah, blah, blah. It has these features, right?
So when you see- Serial number or something. When you see these features, you give a document this score. When you see these other features, you give a document this other score, right?
This is relatively objective. Right. So that’s the point.
So there is value in having, you know, workflows that revolve around tasks that are measurable, not just in a, my APM is up kind of subjective way, right? Going back to what I call the effective design of LLMs, which you can only judge them if you’re using them as the tech pros, the oligarchy has intended, is just, wow, these outputs really match my either feeling or whatever. I’m going to run with them.
I like this, right? And now you’re putting it into a workflow where it’s like, no, now we’ve got some external validation of, did it actually meet this criteria? Now, this does not make the technology valuable.
I think it was incredibly wasteful that we had this bubble. But again, the local models aren’t going away and very likely even when, or if OpenAI and Anthropic implode, their models probably aren’t going away. Some tech companies like Google or Amazon or whoever will scoop up their models, right?
It’s just that they will be put towards boring and hopefully less harmful uses and- I think they could still go on the margins being ambitious uses, but they will probably be bespoke and mundane.
[Nick]
The kind of over radical and drastic over-promising we are currently witnessing.
[Mike]
Oh, right.
[Nick]
That has to subside at some point.
[Mike]
That over-promising. I mean, yeah, the mismatch again of the bubble is, and we can get into this because it goes back to us exploring this question of the permanent underclass. The big misalignment of the bubble is these guys, many of them thought that they were making AGI, artificial general intelligence.
And so they were promising God or a machine that could do anything because they believed it was imminently possible.
[Nick]
Now, which- Even in their early stages, they saw line goes up, its capabilities are increasing. Therefore, at some point, it has to be AGI.
[Mike]
Yeah, so- It was a presumption. If you even look at the academic literature, at least on this side of the machine learning divide, I’m thinking of people like Richard Sutton, who was a prominent researcher. There are people, and I don’t know if this is exactly Sutton.
I mean, Sutton has this thing called the bitter lesson, which revolves around you can have a very simple algorithm. And in some ways, scaling that up is actually more efficient than trying to create bespoke rules that anticipate certain contingencies and whatnot. So for example, a lot of AI’s earliest days, and I use AI in this sense deliberately.
Dear listener, if you remember in the last episode, I was talking extensively about separating all these technologies from another. But I’m using AI deliberately in this case. The history of AI begins with what are called, I guess you could say, rules-based AI.
They call it good old-fashioned AI. Basically, logic and symbolic AI built on rules, code, schema that tell a machine what to do in specific cases. So to give you an analog- It sounds very early on to my ears.
I mean, good old-fashioned AI actually has never gone away. And in fact, actually, some of the irony is that one of the reasons why LLM scaled is because, well, after the models stopped getting better, what the language learning labs did, they started building bespoke scaffolding and tooling that made the models perform better on tasks, even if the models themselves were not getting more capable. You get what I’m saying?
So they began adding back some of these rules and tool sets from the old days of AI. Not literally, but the premise is, because in the machine learning era, there’s this divide of like, okay, do we even need good old-fashioned AI anymore? We’ve got these algorithms that can learn and self-improve on their own.
Well, it turns out the reason why people were going apeshit starting around late 2024, 2025, was because the labs had begun building workflows. They’d begun building workflows that would actually apply to specific tasks. And the model began to get better at those specific tasks because it had the right tooling to do those tasks, as opposed to just the model getting, quote, unquote, smarter.
Now, they were telling us, our models are getting too good too quickly. And that was kind of true around 2023, 2024. So the leap between, say, GPT-2 to GPT-3 was a big deal, because before GPT-2 was just like, it was literally autocomplete.
I know people say AI is just spicy autocomplete. That is true. We can go back to the Grandpa Shelby example and say that language understanding gets you certain things for free.
And that’s why LLMs are a little bit more than just autocomplete. But back in the earlier days, they were literally just autocomplete. And at some point, when they began training in more data and made the models bigger, they began to exhibit other modalities.
Now, their ability to do these things was limited, but they were able to do lots of little bits of lots of things, which gave the illusion of there being something here. Even for me, and I’m sorry I’m dominating, but even for me, I was an AI skeptic. I’m very close to somebody who was an AGI doomer.
And people in our community are, so it’s kind of all around us. It’s true. SF is so weird, though, because you’ve got this hybrid of people who are equally optimistic and equally pessimistic.
And in my circles, they were doomers.
[Nick]
Because they are simultaneously, the important element of that is they are enamored of their growth and the capabilities.
[Mike]
They are seeing the line go up. Their emotional reaction can be either. They are flip sides of the same coin.
But I knew doomers, and maybe you may know a booster or whatever. And in 2023-ish, when I was predicting, because early on, and I say in 2021, you’ve got people trying to create, I guess, policy-based models, which I don’t want to go into technicality. But there’s this idea that started appearing in the early 2020s that you could have basically a model trained in one area would have some transfer learning in other areas.
And so I made a bet with a friend who was a doomer. And I was like, I don’t understand it. Transfer learning probably is useful in the margins.
I could see a model that’s good at math, maybe some of that logic translates to basic programming. Because some programming code involves numbers. I’m not saying all of it does.
But transfer learning appeared to be much broader than it otherwise would have. And so as the model started scaling, the jump to GPT-2 to 3, to 3.5, to 4, it actually freaked me out. I was like, oh my God, am I going to become Yudakowsky and doomer?
But then I got in my home lab, I started playing with these models. It’s like, okay, that’s not what’s happening here.
[Nick]
And it’s somewhat illusory as you’re witnessing it.
[Mike]
And I think for me personally, the reason why this all played out this way is I think language itself encodes a lot of these modalities. And I think I mentioned this discussion, this talk in the last episode. There is a old veteran AI researcher, Michael Woodruff, I believe is his name.
He gave a talk for the Royal Society. This is not the AI we were promised. He says the same thing.
So it’s not just me using my Grandpa Shelby metaphor. There are people in the field who are alluding to the same thing. Language packs in a lot of these features that give the kind of like a little bit of affordance towards doing some types of tasks for a machine.
Now, that does not mean we get what we were promised.
[Nick]
These AI bros have oversold and overpromised us something that is not- If anything, it means that language itself already has baked in so many of these sort of vergences that it’s handing off. It’s allowing the capabilities of these LLMs later on to thrive.
[Mike]
Yes, yes. No, I mean, yeah, the modality comes from language use.
[Nick]
Props to the people, not to the programs. Yeah. Yeah.
[Mike]
Yeah. But in this nugget of Doomers and boosters, right, there is a question of, where did this permanent underclass narrative come from? You and I were talking about this a little bit before.
Obviously, it’s not that we don’t see eye to eye, but I think there’s a bit of unpacking of- Two different AI skeptics don’t agree. My God. Every AI skeptic has been on the same page.
They have the same beliefs. I can’t be an AI skeptic and use AI at the same time. We need to assemble the brigade today.
But yeah, there’s a sense of where this narrative came from and who’s kind of pushing the narrative, per se, right? And for you, I mean, I know your first-hand or second-hand experience is like, what is that sense for you?
[Nick]
Well, and it comes from the first time I was exposed even to the phrase, in this era, the permanent underclass was a very top-down agenda, not conspiracy. Where’s the sort of figures on top, the founders, the designers, the Elon Musks, et cetera, et cetera, were the ones enamored of this, oh, the coming permanent underclass is right ahead. I, with all my wealth, need to be prepared for it, need to be on top as this radical shift occurs.
So again, that’s a very top-down thing and no phenomenon is ever just top-down, right?
[Mike]
Yeah, yeah. I mean, for my lens, unpacking the AI bubble, there’s really a lot of narrative threads here because there are different parties, right? So I just told a long roundabout story about the people who were saying scale is all you need, and then hitting a wall, and then turning back to good old-fashioned AI to rules and scaffolding and tooling to have machines that did stuff.
And so you have true believers, right, who were part of this camp who, I think that the doers and the boosters, by boosters, I don’t just mean people who are AI bros, I mean people who are actually- True believers. No, well, true believers in the sense that they’re techno-alchemists, right? So they’re people who are like, so there’s a coin, one side of the coin is, there’s a guy named Eleizer Yudkowsky, you may have heard of him, but for those of you who don’t know, he’s like a neckbeard who, for some reason, the media has turned to to talk about AI doom, right?
So he’s one of the key voices leading us into discussing the possibility of AI killing everyone on Earth, and literally everything in the light cone of this planet. So if you can see it in space, the AI will colonize it, literally, it’s like a 4X game, it will colonize every planet, every species, every asteroid it encounters to maximize whatever the fuck its objective function is.
[Nick]
Right. And he’s in the Bay Area and also he’s promoting himself as this kind of expert.
[Mike]
Right. And on the flip side of that coin is a techno-optimist who’s not just a booster today who’s like, oh yeah, my APM is up, but not only is my APM up, but in 10 years, imagine how far in the light cone the AI species will travel, right? Some of these people, I say optimists kind of lightly because some of them generally are utopian, some of them are optimists in the sense that they think that they agree with Yudkowsky, like, okay, AI will kill everybody, but that’s actually good because the species that supplants us, this superseding species of AI will be better than us in every way that we should want to become mulch for these creatures, because that’s how you maximize utility in the universe, right? Yeah, this is kind of a bad script doctoring of Skynet and the Terminator scenario, but that is essentially what they’re talking about, expanded into the Terminator if, I guess, Sarah Connor wanted to help the machines replace humans.
Conquer the earth and then leave the earth and then continue being Terminators. This is more closer to maybe some Japanese anime where it’s like, you know, these stories where the villain wants to kind of replace the world with another world, right? Final Fantasy, was it six like that?
Which one had that plot? Five did. Okay, I’m sorry, yeah, five.
Right, this is like a very common plot in Japanese media where it’s like the villain literally wants to replace the world with another world, right? A better world, a purer world that is purer by some metric of their own imagining. And inevitably, notably, one in their direct control.
[Nick]
And that is the obsession of, again, from my point of view, these oligarchic figures, their inspiration, like Sam Altman, is trying to sell this idea. Again, we cannot peer into his mind, but trying to sell the idea of this permanent shift in the capabilities and economic outcomes of the entire world is imminent due to the emergence of AI. And you got to get on the right side now.
So the ownership class, shifting all of their resources into these companies and these projects and data centers, et cetera, et cetera, are trying to position themselves on top to not survive it, but thrive in this new era. And that is the sort of top-down view of the permanent underclass. Can we speak to the experiences of the kind of men and women in the middle?
The worker, the worker would be the engineer who is that, well, I too want to survive. I don’t want to be thrust, pushed all the way back down to the bottom of the food chain in this new labor economy.
[Mike]
So there’s something to what you’re saying. I think the commonality of all these people was that there is a shift, right? But their views are different, right?
So I’m laying the table— It’s difficult to paint them with one brush.
[Nick]
Yeah. But the they want to be on top when the change occurs motif is itself relatively consistent.
[Mike]
Not completely. So for some of these people, yeah, I’m laying out the rogues gallery of characters here just to show you the variance actually in all these views. Like the people who are talking about being mulch, they literally think they are going to die and they are happy with that because they want a progenitor that is better than them in every way, right?
[Nick]
They want to a given birth to the next thing. Right. Which is obviously is edgy teenager shit, but— Get it into the minds of as many people as possible right now and to scare and intimidate and influence— The career aspirations of people who we know and are working— I mean, this is definitely a subset.
[Mike]
Although, supposedly, I believe Musk and somebody argued about this. So Musk purportedly is not on the sublimate everyone side. I mean, not to his credit, but because he wants to—closer to your point, he wants to rule over the future, right?
Not be mulch, but— Yes, our God Emperor of Mars, for sure. Yeah. Right.
But yeah, you have even within the people who are kind of like, let’s say, naive or I guess for lack of a more nuanced word, kind of like emphatic about AI capabilities, right? In either direction, the direction where it kills us, the direction where it helps us, even within that group, you have this kind of kerfuffle of people who are like, okay, I want to be on the team that is not part of the permanent underclass, or I want to be on the team that is going to usher in the future of intelligence in the universe, which is the side that they want extinction, but they just want to be—they want to bring about the extinction themselves, right?
[Nick]
For anybody at home who’s like, when did this come to influence predominate sort of the debate? The answer is very quickly in the last couple of years, and you are sharing the sentiment of our—of my personal hero, Han Solo, I’m out of it for a little while, and everybody gets delusions of grandeur.
[Mike]
Like, that’s where we’re at. This is the delusions of grandeur. The insane thing is, okay, I mean, I know I live here, right?
So, of course, I’m familiar with stuff. I never thought this knowledge would be useful to understand the cultural milieu, let alone the economic machinations of the broader economy. Take over the whole zeitgeist.
Right, but like, these were the voices in Silicon Valley. They didn’t come from nowhere. Eleazar has been here.
[Nick]
They’ve been here the whole time.
[Mike]
They’ve been here the whole time.
[Nick]
Yes, the call was coming from inside the building.
[Mike]
And so, you guys now are learning what I had to learn, you know, I would say seven, eight, nine years ago. Welcome to the jungle. Right.
I mean, when I was learning this, I didn’t think it was relevant. I was like, I know about some eccentric people. Cool.
I mean, hopefully, this knowledge is never useful. And now, it’s like, oh, my God. But then, Sam Ullman wasn’t even a billionaire, so.
Right. So, speaking of Sam Ullman, I don’t think he belongs to this permanent underclass idea. I mean, maybe— What bucket should we put him in?
Yeah, so, let me try and lay out the buckets. I know I’ve been—I’m sorry to your listener, I’ve been kind of roundabout. It’s just that within these buckets, you’ve got these weird subgroups.
But let’s just set up the broad table here. Bucket one are people who believe in capabilities in either direction. Let’s just say they are AI hypists, right?
They believe in AGI, either destructive AGI or productive. All true believers go here. Okay.
All the true believers go here. They don’t agree, right? They’re people who want to use this to create a permanent underclass.
They’re people who think it’s going to kill everybody. They’re people who want to bring about the extinction of everybody because that’s actually good for some reason, right? So, this bucket is a true believer bucket.
They believe in AGI. I don’t know what they do or what they’re doing now that is becoming more and more apparent that we’re not getting AGI yet. Bucket two, I would say, are managers, right?
So, this is probably more to the listener’s sort of day-to-day experience, right? Managers are people who are in positions to deploy AI or to influence AI deployment. And so, managers can be people who are either bought into the delusion.
A lot of them are kind of getting there. They’re going through their paces right now because as the AI agents burn through their tokens, they’re being asked, hey, why are we spending thousands of dollars per day and nothing’s changed about our company fundamentally, right? These are like mid-level, white-collar managers, right?
So, some of the managers are actual…
[Nick]
Maybe they used to be technicians, but they’ve come up into the phase of how I’m getting to choose how to deploy this within a company.
[Mike]
So, some of the managers are people who fell the wools in their eyes. They fell for it. In some sense, they kind of are similar to the guys in the first bucket.
They are true believers in maybe not the AGI vision, but the fact that LLMs today are delivering way more value than they are. And so, they are emphatically pushing it on everybody because they believe it to be true. Now, I don’t have a sense of if the current deflating of the bubble is kind of giving these people room for pause.
But as late as this month, there are people demoing tens of thousands of dollars worth of AI demos, kind of just plowing through tokens and not caring. So, maybe they still walk among us. And then the other half of this bucket is just, there are managers who don’t believe in the capabilities of current LLMs, but they want to seem like someone who is because it’s the current thing in fashion.
And for their own job security, if they’re the ones who are kind of setting the pace of AI deployment in their companies, they can keep their jobs safe and secure, right? So, if you’re the one kind of telling everyone, this is where AI should go, not towards my job, but towards those jobs over there, AI goes over there. And you seem like you know what you’re talking about.
Everyone’s going to defer to you as sort of like the voice of AI at your company, right?
[Nick]
So, it’s a combination of staying on trend, but also deploying these systems almost offensively.
[Mike]
Right. It’s almost a bit of a witch hunt. You’re the witch.
You’re redirecting the hunters. And you’re masquerading as the witch hunter general. Right.
You’re like, you go over there. I’m not one of them. We love AI here.
And you guys should be put over there, right? And I know what I’m talking about. You guys better make sure AI is all in those places.
Right. Yeah. So, bucket three is, I would say, tech leaders, right?
And so, there’s some sense in which, you know, there are people who actually are closer to technology. And they probably knew all along that this was not sustainable or viable or valuable.
[Nick]
This is… That the use cases were not as numerous or as essential as were being advertised. Yeah.
[Mike]
I mean, I’m sure amongst some of these leaders, some of the people probably fall in the bucket one. So, I don’t want to kind of pretend that every tech leader is technically deploying AI knowing it didn’t work. Regardless, they are responsible for these.
[Nick]
But they’re culpable enough because they do have a background in the technical side. And they’re not just misguided business heads. Oh, absolutely.
[Mike]
Absolutely. There’s no doubt about that. Yeah.
But there is some sense in which, you know, the incentives for these guys is just, hey, the world went apeshit when Sam Ulman released GPT was 3.5. And everyone’s stocks went up. And so, if you are going to be a good leader for your shareholders, you’re going to make that stock grow by leaning into the thing everyone’s screaming about, right? So, of course, you’re going to say AI, AI, AI over and over and over and over again.
Even if you know that it’s not as big a deal as they’re saying it is.
[Nick]
Right? So, let me give you an antidote. Be an innovator.
At least be, I don’t know, at least be an excavator. Be a booster of it, right?
[Mike]
Yeah. Yeah. And I’m not trying to make these guys more sympathetic than they, I’m not trying to make them sympathetic at all is what I’m trying to say.
But just to understand their incentives, it’s like their companies, you know, had kind of structured set growth. AI provided a breakout opportunity. They are, you know, fiduciarily kind of obligated to grow the company stock.
It’s just how- Yeah. They have to chase that dragon as they see their duties. And all their peers were doing it, right?
And so, you know, why not do it? To give you an example of this sort of approach is, there’s one story where Jensen Huang was asked about, Jensen was asked about the future of quantum computing, okay? And he said something that was like kind of dismissive of it, because like someone was hyping up, they’re like, AI is going to lead to quantum computing like very shortly, something like that.
I don’t remember the exact story, but something like that. And, you know, Jensen, you know, added some reality to the situation, which is like, you know, like those things aren’t related and quantum’s not like a thing yet. And like- This is not even applicable.
[Nick]
Just, if you’re being at all honest, you can’t make that statement.
[Mike]
And then he caused like some stocks to tumble, right? And so, you know, if this is the reality, and your incentives are to provide a return for asset holders, some of which include our retirement funds, again, I’m not saying we’re culpable personally, I’m just saying, this is a system we are all shackled to, then these guys are just sort of playing their part, you know, like, and obviously there’s, you know, we could be saying, hey, why don’t you actually speak out, right?
If you see something, you know, say something, right? But, you know, if your peers aren’t doing it, and you’re the idiot kind of ignoring free money, your shareholders are going to rake you over some coals and- Their ethos is, if you see something, sell something. Yeah.
I mean, that’s the case definitely partially because, well, one, even if they were responsive to this nuance, their peers probably weren’t. There’s a prisoner’s dilemma here. And that’s sort of inescapable and unavoidable unless you, you know, have a society where people can solve collective action problems and or there’s an incentive to, right?
[Nick]
So they must defect in order to betray their peers simply, in their mind, simply to stay relevant. Right. Yeah.
[Mike]
I think there might be, there’s at least two more buckets, but I think the one that matters and the one I think you’re kind of pointing to is like, the guys at the absolute apex, the guys at the top, was it Sam Altman’s of the world, Elon Musk of the world? This is the ownership class, is what we’re talking about. What do they believe, right?
And I think, I think once you get this high up, you’re kind of dealing with personalities as opposed to dealing with a particular class of interest. And so all of these guys, like they have idiosyncrasies that make them, that make you kind of want to tackle them differently. I don’t know how much this matters.
And individually, because they’re so. A little bit.
[Nick]
Yeah.
[Mike]
I mean, I don’t know how much this matters. This reminds me of a conversation that Karen Howe, who wrote Empires of AI, where she was embedded at OpenAI kind of early on into their existence, right as they were kind of moonshotting. So Karen Howe had a conversation with Ed Zitron, again, famous bubble popper.
And Karen was kind of pointing out, because Ed was kind of pressuring her on like, how do these people believe this nonsense? Are there people who actually believe, kind of going over the buckets I’ve talked about, she kind of touched on them, not in this structure. But as far as I know, I’m the one, one of the few people who put this together in this way.
But she was gesturing at there being people who are true believers who, you know, and so. Shout out to Karen Howe, come on the podcast. You know, and it’s like, there cannot be people who believe this.
He was kind of saying, he’s like, you know, there’s a class of person who is saying these things so they can get money and they can get, you know, power and whatever. And I think that is true. I think even within the buckets we’ve said, there are people who are very clearly oriented that way.
But like, there are also people who are in these buckets who generally believe because either they were, the effective design of LLM made them fall in love with it, or they were based off their machine learning knowledge, kind of just enthralled by the idea of encoding intelligence in machines like this. Right. So to give you an example from the upper echelon class, Dario Almaday, I believe that’s how you say his name, the CEO of Anthropic, okay, was an open AI researcher.
And he and a cohort of people left open AI because they weren’t doing safety good enough. Okay. He left in protest.
Yeah, effectively. Right.
[Nick]
This is that led to the ouster of Sam Altman in its original?
[Mike]
No, no, no, no, no.
[Nick]
This is not that time.
[Mike]
Anthropic is before that.
[Nick]
Oh, Anthropic is before that, okay.
[Mike]
The ouster though does involve people. And we can talk about that. We did a little bit in the last episode.
The safety minded people. The safety minded people. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Yeah, yeah. Okay. But the ouster is just literally kicking Sam out of the company.
Right. But separately from that, there are researchers who left open AI beforehand because they’re like, you know, open AI is not safety minded. Um, and so Dario studied, um, uh, I want to say studying neuroscience and then computer science or cognitive science.
Um, I believe that’s what he studied. Deeply interested in this question of intelligence, deeply worried about AI alignment. And so for years, like he spent like his professional academic career kind of on these questions.
Uh, and so, you know, he, when he goes over to Anthropic, like, yes, it’s a money-making machine, or that’s what they’re trying to build. I don’t think that that disposition disappears. Now his incentives obviously change.
Right. Um, but I do think Anamide is, is separate from, from Sam, not because he is a, he’s safe, he’s safer and he’s, he’s more secure. Uh, in fact, in some ways.
Anamide might be more dangerous because he actually believes something and might be emphatic about that. Right. Whereas an all men reads more like a kind of, uh, you know, uh, a blank slate, if you will.
Right. Someone who will say anything.
[Nick]
Sam Altman is just a George Costanza principle of it’s not a lie if you believe it’s true. Right. I think that’s, again, without getting to the depths of his, his mind, I I’ve safely and firmly said that for a while.
Right.
[Mike]
So you, you, you have in this, this last bucket, you know, a group of people who they belong together because of their class and because they’re similarities, but like each of them has different reasons for acting the way they do. Sometimes they act in concert, but in a lot of ways, it’s not necessarily that they’re, they’re acting together. It’s, it’s just that they’re, I think their incentive structures individually lead them to act this way.
Even if they are dispositionally different, uh, Elon Musk, another example of this group. I mean, Elon is probably the more, well, for me personally, harder to read. Um, you know, Elon was talking about the Yudakowsky and AI doom view since the 2010s.
Um, he literally famously said AI is like summoning the demon, um, back in the early, um, um, I think 2014 is when he said this.
[Nick]
He’s kind of a pupil of that, that school for a while.
[Mike]
He read, he read Nick Bostrom. I think Bostrom has connections to, to, to Yudakowsky. Yeah.
Right. All this, this idea of super intelligence, right. To the original Berkeley click that is still there essentially.
Yeah. Bostrom is, is Oxford, but I, I think via, via the broader, I guess you could say effective altruist slash rationalist project. Hey, these are the EA folks.
[Nick]
I’m sure our audience has heard some little snippet of this at some point for sure.
[Mike]
Right.
[Nick]
Yeah.
[Mike]
So, uh, and I use EA loosely because technically you could say Eleazar and Bostrom aren’t EAs, but they are, there is this broader, I would call it a diaspora of people who are, um, rationalists, I guess is what you would call the broader culture, Bay Area rationalist. And of, of that diaspora, you’d get all these groups like EA, a long-termist, which is kind of like EA, Sam Bacon, freed, long-termist is more like, I think Jeff Bezos considers himself a long-termist.
[Nick]
And we’ll come back to Jeff Bezos in a second, but yeah, that’s, that’s who we’re kind of putting on this big dartboard.
[Mike]
Right. So Elon has kind of waffled between Dario’s position and Sam’s position, but also Elon, in some ways he’s, he’s more legible than them. Cause he’s obviously a Craven capitalist.
Right. Um, you know, to some extent, Elon will, will just like Sam will say and do whatever benefits them in the moment. Right.
I mean, what, what came out of the, the, the trial between him and Sam, it was must money that actually seeded opening eye as a nonprofit. Because again, Eliezer specifically Eliezer and Bostrom had convinced Elon to put money towards saving us, you know, quote unquote, saving us from AGI.
[Nick]
From this demon that they were something.
[Mike]
Right. Yeah. Um, now back then opening, I wasn’t making a, a, a product, um, they were doing research for profit.
Right.
[Nick]
So, you know, but in, in this pursuit of, of, of, of, um, can I just say, it’s still funny that in the, in the open trial between Sam Altman, the known liar and Elon Musk, you know, the, the awfulest guy in any room that it’s Elon Musk who loses. I think that’s fascinating.
[Mike]
He on the merits clearly, but it’s most of his, most of his, uh, most of his stuff is self owning. That’s his, that’s his specialty.
[Nick]
Yeah.
[Mike]
Yeah. When he wins is it’s just because I guess there’s, there’s just the barrier to, um, to, to, to, uh, stopping him was, was too high, but like it, it, he’s sort of, um, and we could talk about this later, you know, my thoughts about it.
[Nick]
We’ll come back around to it. No, the point is in the, in the trial, a lot of this is revealed to sort of the original sin of where these, these deals were made to fund it, to push it. And that’s where Sam Altman got his funding.
[Mike]
Yeah. So early on, actually, I think, I forget what year it’s came out in the trial. Elon is egging opening eye when, when they had, had, had like, I guess a small breakthrough, um, to become a for-profit.
Um, so it’s like, this is the guy that was publicly, you know, biting his nails about AGI. And then, you know, uh, when, when it becomes possible to monetize it, he tries to monetize it. He wanted to roll open AI into Tesla.
And ironically, if that had happened, we may not have the AI bubble as it, as it exists today. Elon Musk could have possibly saved us from, um, this entire nightmare, this entire nightmare.
[Nick]
Well, cause if he’s like, Oh, we’re summoning a demon. And then he pays to fuel the summoning of that demon. That’s hypocritical at best.
[Mike]
It’s hypocritical at best. One read is that cynical. It, one read of, of, of, of that is when he created Grock, he was saying something like, Oh, well, cause he’s, he’s a, he’s an idiot, obviously.
Um, but to the extent he understands these subcultures and these subcultures are also full of idiots too. But to the extent he, he, he understands these very wealthy, educated idiots. So, you know, right.
To the extent he understands what these guys are saying, he’s like, Oh, you know what, if we make an AI that just wants to seek the truth, they won’t kill us. Right. So if he, if he, if he actually believes that, right, this is the loophole in his mind that will, you know, I’m, this is us mind reading.
I’m not saying I know we’re having to read the tea leaves in Musk heart of hearts. Right. If, if, if Musk actually believes this, this, this loophole, right.
This idea that making a maximally truth seeking AI will save everybody. It allows him to be consistent. He was afraid of the demon back when we didn’t understand that maximally truth seeking AI could be made.
And that, that, that’s how you avoid possible. Right. Yeah.
And then, you know, concurrently as his business interests change, well, you can solve this problem with the maximum truth is the AI of course.
[Nick]
And his beliefs and his fears also change to align with the profit motive. Yeah. Typically and inexorably.
Yeah. So I said a second ago, and I’m so grateful that you set up like these different buckets to put these sort of deplorable figures in either culpable or truly terrible. Um, I want to ground this in a specific example, just so we can examine it, you know, a little more gristle off the bone here.
Um, very recently it was revealed and announced and hyped that Amazon behind the scenes, Jeff Bezos personally was leading an effort to implement, uh, large swaths of AI decision making and services within Amazon itself. It went horribly by all metrics.
[Mike]
Is it Bezos or is it Jassy? Bezos is, is out of Amazon. I think it was Jassy, right?
[Nick]
I mean, Bezos was pushing it, like saying, oh, this is interesting in terms of who was on the ground behind, you know, I don’t know whose head should roll for this, but it resulted in, uh, you know, crashing of something that should never crash, which is the Amazon, uh, storefront. Oh yeah. There’d be a terrible amount of screw ups on orders.
Like if, if, if we are sort of, you know, inherent in the example of why is Facebook great? Because Facebook never goes down. Then that’s the only rule.
That’s the only metric for the success of Facebook. And that’s, that’s fine. That works.
Amazon is at least your, you know, basket never gets emptied randomly, right? You know, it remembers the stuff you want to buy. Even if you’re like, I shouldn’t be buying all this stuff, but at least Amazon remembers even that fundamental lowest level, lowest threshold for success was botched because they said they got so excited.
They got so in their own heads about it, that this AI capabilities were true and that they were going to follow it up and it was going to make everybody all this money. And therefore they could fire or reposition all of their employees. It was going to make everything better.
And now we’ve seen it at scale for the first time in a huge tech company like Amazon.
[Mike]
Yeah. Yeah.
[Nick]
This is a story playing out, you know, in real time right now, as of the publishing of this, of this, uh, this episode.
[Mike]
Oh no, not just that story. But so, so that, that, that Amazon reporting is back from March. I talked about it in my, uh, what to expect when you’re expecting the AI bubble.
[Nick]
Um, so that’s a misaligned market. Check it out now.
[Mike]
So, you know, that idea, I mean, like those stories were happening and, and those companies like Amazon were at the vanguard of, of that, uh, I guess, uh, comedy of errors, I guess you could say. Um, and what surprised me is after that reporting, you know, uh, I have friends and, and, and, um, you know, I know of companies in the area that as late as April and, and, and May were kind of accelerating their, their AI adoption after reading stories like Amazon having those major issues. Um, so at this stage where we’re at is.
These are now second order effects.
[Nick]
Yeah. The, the willingness of, of the, the, you know, the Amazon heads to adopt this, regardless of the result, which was a terrible result, objectively has now encouraging other firms, smaller competitors, bigger ones to say, oh, well, it’s legitimate now because they’re doing it. We get to do it, or we ought to, we have to, to avoid becoming pushed out of the permanent underclass, right?
This is now the, the, you know, how we have to contend with this.
[Mike]
And now the, the irony is the, I mean, everyone’s starting to hit the wall at the same time, right? So you got a token spend is out of control. Uh, Uber went through their, um, entire year’s budget.
I think I mentioned this in the last episode. Their entire token budget. They’re for the year and in four months.
They’re fine. And there is a company, um, this came out even more recently since the last episode. This is newer.
There’s an unnamed company, unnamed Sora said because they did not meter their company’s token spend. They spent, I think like 500, 500 million on, uh, AI costs this quarter. They didn’t mean to.
[Nick]
That’s my, they accidentally spent $5 million, $5 million, $5 million. I think so. I have to check the, yeah.
Yeah. Just check the episode notes for that one. That’s a good grief.
Uh, that’s ridiculous. Yeah. So this is sort of like, what is there a stockholder revolt sort of against, right?
Because second order effects is one thing. That’s kind of the people, the business heads in the one bucket, all kind of hyping each other up. But there are other ownership groups that have to say at some point you are literally burning through all of our cash.
This is our money. They do have rights. Like I haven’t really witnessed that yet.
Maybe because the, the, the bills and the rental, the rental arms of the flags aren’t being raised high enough. Yeah. So this is interesting, right?
[Mike]
So on this podcast, I mean, you know, um, so I laid out the buckets of people who are kind of like the core actors, you know, of, of the, of like the bubble from the tech side for the rest of society, we’ve obviously got investors and we’ve got the media. The media has just been saying, this is the fourth industrial revolution. Don’t get left behind.
Right. And in some sense, the media is actually where the permanent underclass idea, I don’t want to say it originates, but where it gets steamed. I think within tech itself, you have obviously, um, people who are upper middle class, right.
Who, um, there’s a good, good video on this by, um, um, how many works where he’s talking about basically. And I, I agree with this, you know, Silicon Valley was sort of the last egalitarian bastion. I, I put this in quotes because obviously meritocracy, right.
Where it’s like, if you come here and you work hard and you got equity in the right company, you could actually have a good life. Right. You put in the work, you get the equity, you exit.
Right. And you did something for the world at the same time, right. How the world should work.
Right. That’s, that’s why there is such this, this, this, this mythos and this, this, this sort of air of, of, um, even moral kind of like a finality of Silicon Valley is like this. If, if, if the nineties was the end of history, Silicon Valley is sort of what that looks like.
Right. Um, and you know, in theory, right. In quotes, right.
[Nick]
Does that make Palo Alto the city on a hill? Like, is that essentially what was being sold as an idea?
[Mike]
I mean, no one said this out loud. I’m saying this is sort of like, you know, this is sort of what people, you know, quietly said, this is how it should work. Right.
People come in, they put in their hours, they get equity, they get to the exit. They did something for the world. This is why the system, and you can fill in the blank for what the system is.
It could be capitalism as a whole, could just be a tech technocracy could be just, you know, um, tech companies as a whole, right. Whatever, all of these sort of like modern technocratic apparatuses. This is why they work.
Right. Look at the results. People who are, who were, you know, who came in here, who were poor and went to college and studied computer science.
That’s why everyone should code became such a, a, a, a moniker, because this was proving the vision of what, you know, the end of history should look like. What it was expected to look like. And so the people buying into the permanent underclass narrative now see that, you know, well, that was kind of a lie.
Now that all the VC money is locked up in AI and AI increases your APM. Well, time to, you know, join the side that, that is pushing AI for whatever reason, right. Whether they’re doomers, boosters, nihilists that want us all to die.
Elon Musk, right. Dario Amadei, who wants to save us while working on AI, right. Regardless of why they are boosting AI, join them so that you’re not in the permanent underclass when the AI inevitably increases your APM and everyone else’s APM is too low to keep up with you.
Right. So media is important part of obviously feeding that fear. Every time they were reporting job loss numbers, like a fricking horse race, right.
They are feeding the idea that it’s coming, it’s coming. Everyone’s losing their job to AI. Now they’ve started walking back as a bubble has become harder and harder to deny.
But the damage of the idea was done. I mean, there are people still even now worried about losing jobs to AI, even though I think it’s become apparent that, you know, if you lose your job to AI, it may not be because of AI. It might be because someone wanted to cut costs and they’re just pointing to a, you know, accountability sink to justify their decision.
And you asked a good question about where are the investors? They’re burning money. Are they sleeping at the wheel?
Well, their money is enabling. OpenAI has, I believe, either information or Zitron reported negative 133% operating margins. If you or I had to run a company that poorly, right, we are losing 33 cents for every dollar.
It’s only profitable if you take out all the unprofitable elements. Right. So the investors obviously, well, one, you know, they don’t understand what work is.
[Nick]
Yes. And they’re also, you know, let’s, let’s point out another sort of not a new bucket, but another element of this, of the, of this network, this, this web. And those are media figures and critics who are enamored of and have been, you know, tech journalists for a long time, starting as far back as the era of Steve Jobs were sort of hero worshipers.
And that was a critique that was very much eventually validated within tech journalism. They’re great. We have to stop worshiping these heroes.
Back then, you know, when Elon Musk was Iron Man and Steve Jobs was still alive and he was still this aspirational figure. Now, because they’re not permitted to become these fan boys and girls, they have to still sell something and they’re selling and therefore perpetuating the myth around AI. And therefore a lot of these associated myths, like the permanent underclass, they’re selling this whole package and investors seemingly are buying it.
Eventually, you know, it comes down to basic taxpayers are buying it. And as much as there is now a better understanding of the, the, the basic elements of all these systems and how they’re not what we were told they were, even as that understanding grows year, you know, month by month, quarter on quarter, year by year, it hasn’t reached a saturation point yet. Seemingly, it hasn’t reached the revolt stage.
And I’m saying that because I’ve been looking around like, and we’ve been commenting to each other. Well, when is that?
[Mike]
Right? Yeah. I mean, there, there are a lot of things at play here.
I mean, the real thing is, so investors don’t know how work works. Right. So they were just like, you know, the the people who are kind of being one-shotted by Claude who are saying my APM is up without understanding if the APM being up is a good thing or a bad thing.
Investors, they can’t read the screen because their, their monocles are too fogged up. Like that’s, I mean, these, these people aren’t, aren’t, aren’t, I mean, I know, I know, I know you are. So these people are like, so just like the workers who are obsessed with APM and, and, and, and, you know, they, they, they’ve been, you know, impressed or enthralled by AI.
[Nick]
Well, and the workers, the worker groups are also doing it because they’re terrified of being downsized. Some of them are.
[Mike]
Rightfully so. Some of them are, some of them are. Some of them are more craven, you’re saying?
The ones I’m specifically thinking about, the ones who are talking about APM, or I’m using APM as my metaphor, but the ones who are obsessing over this, I can do more. And I, just one more token, bro. One more token, bro.
[Nick]
Yeah.
[Mike]
They’re, to the most part, they are well-off tech workers. They are like the upper middle class. They are the people for whom, you know, the promise of meritocracy in Silicon Valley existed and it has gone away or has started to go away.
Right. So they’re. But they’re still subscribed to it.
They’re subscribed to it via the last remaining bastion in their mind, which is get your APM up high enough so that you can, you can escape, you can reach escape velocity. Right. Um, but you know, the, the features of large language models that made these workers susceptible to this idea, the people who should know better, right.
Are the same features that made investors, you know, fall for the delusion too. And it doubly so for investors, cause they don’t do, I mean, not trying to be funny, but they don’t do any work. They don’t do the actual grunt work of, of the, the, the companies that they invest in.
[Nick]
Yeah. As of today, we haven’t reclassified investing as working. And thank God.
So.
[Mike]
Right. Maybe they did at some point in the nineties or whatever, whenever they made their money and exited. Right.
But, but I’m saying like, they are far enough removed from these processes where they are kind of looking over the shoulders of everyone else and saying, oh, that looks good. It looks good. It’s fine.
It’s fine. Right. Because they don’t have any other, other means of doing that.
And now that they know that this has gone on so long, right. Now that no one called foul earlier, even if they know that this is not working out. Their incentive sort of just like all the other people who are, who are trapped, right.
I was talking about, you know, the, the tech CEOs, the leaders who are kind of like, you know, trapped in that they probably know the technology is, is not.
[Nick]
They’re locked in because not only did they make these promises, but they have burned through all this money pursuing these promises. And either it works to some degree that it launches them far enough that like their growth overwhelms the losses, which is also not rational by any metric based on the current losses. And they somehow come out the other side, as you’ve been describing.
[Mike]
Or, you know, they, they know this is not going to work and they’re looking for the exit liquidity. Right. So there’s a story of, of Elon Musk and.
Unload the debt on somebody else. Right. Like the space, the space taxpayer, anybody.
[Nick]
Right, right, right.
[Mike]
The space as IPO, you know, literally, you know, when Nasdaq was, was, was ushering to change the rules, you know, the Nasdaq was fast-tracking space X and a lot of, of regular indexes would get, you know, if they are, if they are, have access to the, to the Nasdaq, you know, would, would get exposure exposure. The S and P didn’t follow suit. But still, you know, you see kind of like the, the, the plan here is like, I think now.
I don’t know who’s, who’s, who, I don’t know who knows what is happening, but obviously amongst the people who are still boosters, I think some of them are cynically. So, right. You’ve been doing this song and dance for so long.
You can’t stop now. You have to keep going. There’s no other way out, but through.
Yeah. Right. Which makes these, some of these people more dangerous.
Right. So I, I believe we still have a bunch of true believers. I think at some point, you know, they’ll wake up, but amongst the people who are pretending to be true believers, I think they are just cynically, their incentives make it such that they, they have to actually keep this song and dance up because they, they, you gotta find a way out.
[Nick]
They are entirely locked into it.
[Mike]
Yeah.
[Nick]
They have to, cause there’s no other way. Um, yeah. And I, I was not, not relieved is the wrong word.
Um, validated recently when I heard, uh, uh, Elon himself speaking on, well, in defense of this behind the scenes merger of, um, uh, his AI company and, and SpaceX. It’s like, yeah, it’s, it’s natural because, you know, and people were questioning like, well, you can slam these two companies together. One is pleading money.
The other is very profitable. And I guess the books work out, but what are the efficiencies? How do they organically fit together?
[Mike]
We’re going to, we’re going to take all the matter in our light cone.
[Nick]
What, what, what, what don’t you understand? Yeah. Well, why are you, why are you so dumb?
You, you media critics. And they’re like, okay, but what’s like the step one. He’s, and you know, all matter in the light cone.
That is the step. What are you, why aren’t you listening to me? And, uh, no, he, he, he said basically, and we’re making fun of like the idea of, oh, they’re going to get everything.
You know, the board resistance is futile. It’s like, yeah, well, we’re going to have, um, data centers more efficiently. We’ll launch them into space and then they’ll, you know, they’ll just cool themselves easier up there.
And that’s, that’s what we’re going to do. That’s what SpaceX is going to do. I was like, my God, he’s finally off his rocker.
He’s saying these words in public data centers in space. Sounds like a rejected comedy bit from the Muppet show. It’s to my ears.
And again, I don’t know what our audience thinks. We’ll find out if, if they’ve, if they continue to do it, I don’t think we’re going to see data centers in space. Mostly because I don’t think we’re going to see data centers in Tennessee.
Like that is also a bubble on its own that is being, being pushed.
[Mike]
So yeah, no, very good. Good call. Yeah.
I mean, I look at the reporting of someone like Zitron, who’s showing a lot of these data centers are not being built or they are behind schedule.
[Nick]
Even as the money sort of on paper been dedicated to it, it’s just piling up debt.
[Mike]
The data center. Yeah, exactly. The data center, the AI bubble, when I said this in the last episode, AI bubble is closer to actually a data center bubble, right?
So you’ve got like a tiny bubble in the, in the form of the AI startups, like Anthropic, OpenAI. And that, that would be bad, you know, by itself, but it wouldn’t be that bad because the, the, the losses would be kind of centered on Silicon Valley.
[Nick]
But the. It couldn’t therefore be just unloaded onto all the rest of the world and the country and other people in classes and such.
[Mike]
Yeah. But the data centers, we’ve got some of the world’s biggest banks have, have invested in, in, in lending money to these. And the, the.
[Nick]
Now it starts to look like 08 again, if we’re getting the banks involved.
[Mike]
The lit, well, it’s, yeah, literally the, the, the debt structures to, to finance these data centers, they resemble some of the, the collateralization we saw in 08. Oh my, it’s terrible. So it literally is like somebody had the bright idea to replicate 08 with data centers.
And, and on top of the banks doing it, we have these entities called private credit or non-depository financial institutions, shadow banks, some people call them. And private credit has lent money for the data centers too. And in some cases they’ve taken money from the bank to lend out to other people to build data centers, right?
So there’s a, a very circle jerky motion, not, you know, not unlike the one in Silicon Valley where the AI companies are feeding each other money, like open AI to NVIDIA, to CoreWeave, et cetera, et cetera. But separately from that AI company bubble, there is a data center bubble that involves these entities, some of which we don’t even know who they are, lending money to build data centers that may not ever be built.
[Nick]
Yeah. And then this self-licking ice cream cone kind of process, you know, I’m thinking now back to the second Trump inauguration and without diverging us right into purely political territory, you know, on stage with the incoming president were all of the great tech oligarchs. And even at that time, there was the plan being pushed for Congress itself on behalf of the American people to pay for, to contribute to and pay for the Stargate initiative.
Right. And I didn’t, you know, I remember the Stargate thing very, eventually going off the headlines and like, it didn’t get picked up by Congress because they hate the idea. It’s clearly a boondoggle.
But the second that Elon said data centers in space, like he’s still trying to get some form of Stargate out there of this, of this concept, like we need to get the American taxpayer on the hook. Otherwise it’s only going to hurt us.
[Mike]
But that’s how their companies work though. I mean, that’s why the Silicon Valley loves working with the government. Right.
So like it’s a natural extension of their existing business relationships. Right. And for Elon specifically, you know, it’s a little hard to know if he is just that big of a, he is dumb, but it’s hard to know how serious he is.
I used to think that it was- At any given time. Right. We don’t know.
So I used to think that some of this stuff was, was, was tactical, not, not to his credit, but you know, but it’s become apparent that, that I think this is what happens when you have too many BS men around you is that your worst impulses are not curtailed. And we’ve seen this with Trump, obviously in every dimension of Trump’s life. And so Elon grew up as a sci-fi nerd.
And like, of course he likes data centers in space. He’s now a billionaire toddler who gets to live out his fantasies and I’m sure data centers in space, it sounds futuristic. It sounds right.
[Nick]
For a person suffering arrested development, as we have all sort of armchair diagnosed him as, this is too perfect for him. Right. For his mindset.
[Mike]
Right. I mean, obviously it doesn’t matter if he believes it or not. Right.
Like, did he, did he believe we’re going to go to Mars? And now he’s saying we’re going to go to the moon, which is, you know, he should have been promising that before Mars. You got a different kind of pitch.
[Nick]
But yeah, I mean. It really only matters if he does get the taxpayer on the hook, which seems to be, they’re constantly probing and poking at. Not just taxpayer, but other.
[Mike]
I mean, like, even though Tesla is a meme stock, right? I mean, they’ve not really created a new car. And I mean, if you call it a car, fine.
But, you know, they haven’t created a new successful vehicle in over a hundred years. So, you know, if these companies are meme stocks and Elon knows he could say whatever to, to rile up the markets, you know, then why not speak a little bit to your childhood fancy, right? Why not kind of placate your inner toddler and just say shit that, you know, will the media, the, you know, uncritical media will just kind of parrot and, and, and, and amplify and, you know, not question you on rent.
[Nick]
Yeah. In that sense, it’s a, if not a great tactic, it’s a great strategy. So in that we are not, we don’t have a defense against it, purely speaking.
Right. Yeah. So having said that, this all sounds like very dire sort of assessment.
Let me inject an idea here that is not, if not hopeful, I think it is revealing.
[Mike]
Yeah.
[Nick]
And that is at a certain point I saw in the permanent underclass discourse, a fear emerge in the eyes and in the, in the, in the sense of these oligarchs. And this was not Elon specifically, but there was reference to a consistent reference to when this new era dawns ahead of us, we all need to have enough wealth put away that we’re not the people relying on UBI.
[Mike]
Yep.
[Nick]
That was the dividing line. There’s going to be, you know, the underclass is fed and watered by UBI. Everybody else has made it.
Their rocket ship took off metaphorically speaking, and they have enough wealth. They can sit on their, their Scrooge McDuck mountain. That’s the distinction.
And as soon as I saw that, I was like, okay, they’re now seeing that there’s enough of a consensus coming around UBI for one thing, that it’s a fear for them. It’s a calculation for them. And this is a tacit admission, I guess is kind of what I’m pointing at.
And it, to me, it’s just not a reveal. It’s a bit of a cell phone in a larger sense, because the, for all of its, you know, the debate around the implementation of UBI, creating cultural and policy consensus was one of the goals of everybody before the era of, of, you know, the tech oligarchy. It was how do we rebalance this equation for the work?
Or how do we build the economy for what it’s meant to be, which is to help in a utilitarian sense, distribute wealth in a, in the, you know, the, the most frictionless way possible. And their fear is actually that wealth will be distributed this way. And they want to stand sort of a, you know, a scant history or thwart history and say, no, they want to stymie this progress.
And I think that is, that’s, that’s them revealing themselves.
[Mike]
This, yeah, your, your, yeah, your diagnosis is right. I think though, the timing is not, timing is not like a particularly interesting thing. Like the real thing is that they’ve been doing this actually for over a decade, right?
So you have Andrew Yang, for example, talking about UBI sort of, you know, obviously Andrew Yang currently aspiring tech bro. Right. Yeah.
I mean, he kind of was, he had a, he had a company as well, you know, but, but are we kind of always has been, I should say. Yeah. Right.
But it’s not just Yang. I mean, actually opening, opening, I, I forget the relationship to this other entity. I want to say it’s, there’s, there’s some research arm in this EA adjacent philanthropy universe.
I forget who, but like, and I believe Sam Altman was, was connected to the study. They did a UBI study. Right.
So this, this was, this was like a while ago. Right. So I’m saying like, like the, the, my, my, my.
[Nick]
I’m thinking about what you’re saying. This was, if I’m not mistaken, Y Combinator was taking pitches for. Uh, design your own UBI distribution system.
Bring it to us and we’ll, we’ll build it.
[Mike]
Yeah. Yeah. I’m sorry.
So I, for some reason I thought it was open philanthropy, but maybe, maybe open philanthropy did their own. I had to double check that. Well, I think that, I think this was kind of in the water, but yeah, but that’s why, that’s what, that’s why I had the Sam Altman connection in my mind.
Y Combinator makes, makes sense. Makes sense. Yeah.
But tech has explored some notion of this for the last 10 years. Cause they were always afraid of, um, you know, quote, unquote, the revolt and they were looking for, for the bread and circuses, even as early as, um, the late Obama years. Right.
And so, you know, they have been trying to get ahead of this, but only always, always, almost always through placation and words. Um, and their preferred UBI strategy of sort of like, in many cases, just, um, having a, a, a, a, a social safety net floor and kind of just leaving it at that and just saying, Hey, we have a lump sum payment you get every month. That’s all you need.
[Nick]
There is no. Even as we are currently fighting against the long time, um, malformed, misformed policy that is minimum wage, they’re like, okay, well, we’ll give you that at least everybody minimum wage. And then we just suppress that as much as we can over time.
Yeah. Which isn’t what UBI was originally conceived of and should not be.
[Mike]
There’s a whole universe of UBI options and a genuine debate would look way more multifaceted. Arguably though, the Y Combinator study did actually provide some, some good ammunition for a more expansive UBI program. Right.
I don’t remember the details though. And I can’t go into like, like super, super great detail, but like, I remember being surprised at the time that, that, that a tech company or a tech adjacent entity was even involved in it. Yeah.
[Nick]
Yeah. It didn’t, it, to me, it didn’t feel like an organic bit. It felt like this was sort of.
They, they, they hired. Inserting themselves.
[Mike]
Moving in again. They, they hired researchers and, you know, with some of these entities that are, um, nonprofits in this space, they do care. Right.
So you have, you know, one, you have arms of these entities that actually actually care about the issues they’re engaging. I mean, you go back to the AI story and what we were talking about in these buckets of people, you got people, you know, who actually care about the thing to the state. Right.
So, um, you brought up early on the, uh, Sam Altman’s Alistair from open AI. Right. That happened because at open AI, there were people who were doers who genuinely believe that AI could kill everybody.
Very depressed moralist. And they were like, Sam Altman is, is, uh, antithetical to the mission of preventing that from happening. Right.
Um, and even amongst people at Anthropic who are probably amongst that bucket one and bucket two, you know, like they, you know, there are people who are in Anthropic who believe AI actually could be a force for good. And they’re, they are trying to find good applications for AI for people who believe AI is a force for bad. And they’re trying to do AI safety research.
Right. You have all these kinds of amalgams of like amalgamations, um, of, of different types of people working together in the same entities, sometimes resulting in, you know, outcomes that are kind of contrary to what you would expect the organization or entity to actually pursue because, well, they’ve got an arm within their institution or whatever that is aligned in this way.
[Nick]
And I think I’ll make a guess. I’ll make a bet here. I feel safe making that bet.
Um, at some point, this UBI program, uh, as it was being designed, would have paid people out in crypto. That’s just a guess, but it feels like the kind of solid top-down manipulation that that was going to be attempted.
[Mike]
I think it was a premise behind Sam Alma’s world coin, which I barely understand.
[Nick]
World coin, yeah.
[Mike]
Yeah, yeah. I mean, world coin is separate from the Y Combinator UBI study. So they’re not one the same, but like, you know, Sam, Sam of a kind though.
Yeah. With Sam, a lot of his stuff just reads like, like grifts. If you, if you know about his first company loot at Y Combinator loot, basically the audacity of naming a company loot, by the way, is not, I’m sure not lost on anybody.
Basically it lied about his subscriber numbers and they were inflated. And, you know, so, so how he kind of put himself on the map, right. So Sam has always been kind of like a bit of a schemer, a scammer, right.
Even more so than, you know, like, again, like not to, you know, I don’t want to make this seem like I’m an Anthropic fanboy. I’m not, but you know, Adario Amadei.
[Nick]
I can confirm you are not an Anthropic fanboy.
[Mike]
Yeah, Adario Amadei actually is not a schemer. He literally was probably, you know, obsessed with his AI question. Just like the Unikowskis of the world who, again, like, you know, as crazy as these people sound, to some extent, you know, actually believe something.
Now, to what extent that has kind of corrupted their kind of like broader sense of understanding of the world and to what extent are the incentives that reward them for having those beliefs, right. So Eliezer, for example, somebody who now gets rewarded for, for repeating this message of doom, even as it’s become apparent that at least for now, LLMs are not going to be the pathway to whatever it is.
[Nick]
Even as the public is increasingly aware and skeptical of these pitches and promises, he is still pushing the doom message with greater and greater intensity.
[Mike]
So there is this, you know, not to focus on any one particular person, but there is this sort of tension that these people genuinely came to this moment as they were with these beliefs, right. But someone like even Eliezer, who does not produce anything, as far as I know, is making, I believe, $400,000 or more with his nonprofit, right. So it’s like, as now you could argue, there is a question of whether or not, you know.
[Nick]
Just his paycheck for working at the nonprofit.
[Mike]
Yes. It might actually be $600,000. I don’t actually know.
In the show notes, listeners, every, every correction or whatever I will issue, I will specifically say all the information I’m saying here. So you have the correct version of subject to the errata of my, my hazy memory of all this chaos of the AI bubble. This is the sea in which we swim.
Yeah. But, but yeah, there’s a question for me. It’s like, okay, like this guy clearly came to this, this, this vision, you know, when you read his early writings, whatever, like he, I think he genuinely believed this.
And then now he’s getting paid $400,000 to $600,000 to say this. And it’s obvious that it’s not true anymore. And he’s not updating his, his, his, his point of view.
Well, maybe the incentives now have captured him such that he, even if he doesn’t believe it anymore, he wants to keep saying it because he gets paid to say it. Right. Same is true for, for Dario.
And you know, he’s not as locked in, but he’s essentially locked in his own path. They’re all locked in, in some way. Right.
[Nick]
Cause they’re either their reputations are staked on it. Right. Their careers, their little like legal culpability, all these things.
[Mike]
They all dovetail. They’re locked in these buckets. Right.
Yeah. Some of these, we can’t, we can’t actually know what they are because it requires mind reading, but like some of these, you can probably assume, you know, like if you’re making that kind of money, you know, it’s probably hard to, to distance yourself from access to that amount of money. Right.
[Nick]
I also would hazard a guess. And again, this is just an assessment based on their skill sets and their training and their, you know, their what school and where they got their degrees or not. I don’t think they have real separate skill sets.
Like they’ve come into a place at a time where tech was sort of on the, on the ascendancy and they went all in because it made sense. And they, they had a, a certain expertise that worked, but they can’t exist in any other frame or in any other era. Um, or at least not in the same way as they would like, as they’d like to, or they couldn’t be the, the expertise.
They couldn’t be the gurus that they have become.
[Mike]
I think it’s right. I think this is the, this is an environment that is perfect for perfect, uh, Vanna for this exact type of call it a grift, call it a, you know, a, a, a vision gone too far. Right.
Whatever it is. Right. And they all came here with their particular idiosyncrasies, whether they were true believers or not, but they all, you know, the result is that they ended up kind of pushing the same, um, um, false narrative that, you know, as it diffused to the media, right.
So, you know, as much as it did, right. To the extent that it did, you know, it kind of just became, look, we’re not going to do the work of picking apart these different buckets, these different people, but many of them are directionally saying either cynically or not that AI is capable of some great things. We’re just gonna repeat this over and over and over again.
So you’re scared about, you know, losing your job and whatnot.
[Nick]
If you flood the zone enough, and this is, you know, the, it creates a kind of inevitability in the minds of, of, uh, the working class and the, uh, the, you know, the middle-class audience for this. And that inevitability is, uh, is intimidating. It’s terrifying.
And, and using phrasing, targeted phrasing, uh, targeted rhetoric, like the permanent underclass, even those words coming out of my mouth, I’m a little bit scared, even as we’ve been sitting here, parsing it and tearing it down. Like it’s a potent set of ideas and phrases, especially when paired with the even more terrifying and potent rise of AI narrative. And, you know, and I think this is a healthy place to wrap up and also to send people, um, immediately after listening to this podcast, uh, please do check out, uh, at Zitron’s Um, and also come on the show anytime I’m going to keep, I’m going to keep learning until it works.
Um, but, uh, a lot of the bubble popping and, and myth bursting, um, I didn’t say myth busting because it’s probably copyrighted, um, has been done by, uh, Ed and, uh, is incredibly valuable to me and to, and to, to Michael as well. Um, is there a particular one you can point them to? I’m trying to think on my own, like it’s type them into YouTube and just start.
If you, if you don’t know his catalog, I’ll put something in the show notes that it’s a good starter.
[Mike]
I can’t off the top of my head, think of anything, but stuff’s moving so fast that like, um, you know, he, he actually showed up on, on Bloomberg, which is like mainstream. He’s now mainstream. Like they’re, we’re at the height of the bubble.
Cause Ed Zitron is on your dad’s Bloomberg terminal.
[Nick]
Yeah. He’s on your dad’s TV, you know, trying to speak truth.
[Mike]
It’s like, this is, this is, I think people are waking up, right. But I will put those in the show notes and all the other references I’ve been making half remembered or totally remembered.
[Nick]
Yeah.
[Mike]
All going to show notes. They’re all there. They’re all there for sure.
[Nick]
Um, uh, so yes, thank you again for joining us on, uh, this episode of, uh, The Last Enclosure. I’ve been Michael. And I’ve been Nick.
And, uh, we’ll see you on the next one. Thank you again.